What is paternity fraud?
Paternity fraud occurs when a mother intentionally misleads a man into believing that he is the biological father of her child. This can happen in a number of ways, including lying about birth control or having a sexual relationship with multiple men at the time of conception. The result of paternity fraud is that a man may unknowingly take on financial, emotional, and legal responsibilities for a child that is not biologically his.
The legal implications of paternity fraud in Australia
In Australia, there is no specific law that addresses paternity fraud. However, there are legal avenues that a man can pursue if he believes he has been the victim of paternity fraud.
The first step for a man who suspects paternity fraud is to request a DNA paternity test. If the test confirms that the man is not the biological father of the child, he can apply to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia for a declaration of non-parentage. This will legally revoke any parental rights or responsibilities that the man may have had for the child.
Another legal avenue for men who have been the victim of paternity fraud is to pursue a civil case against the mother for damages. This can include compensation for any financial losses that the man has incurred as a result of supporting the child, as well as emotional damages such as distress, embarrassment, and loss of reputation.
However, these cases can be difficult to prove, and the burden of proof falls on the man to show that the mother intentionally misled him into believing he was the biological father. Additionally, the damages that a man can recover are often limited, and may not fully compensate him for the losses he has suffered. However, in Magill v Magill [2006] HCA 51; (2006) 231 ALR 277; (2006) 81 ALJR 254 the High Court of Australia considered an appeal in respect of damages the father claims he suffered as a result of paternity fraud where he discovered that two of his three children were not his biological children. The Father initially won an award of $70,000 in the Country Court of Victoria, which was then appealed in the Supreme Court of Victoria and reversed the trial judges decision by stating that the father failed to establish the essential elements of the tort of deceit. The High Court then heard the fathers appeal to restore the initial trial judges award which was refused.
What can men do to protect themselves?
The best way for men to protect themselves against paternity fraud is to take steps to confirm their biological paternity before establishing a relationship with a child. This can include requesting a paternity test at the time of birth, or at any point during the child’s life.
It is important to note that the prevalence of paternity fraud in Australia is difficult to determine, as many cases go unreported. However, The American Association of Blood Banks “(AABB)”, which accredits DNA testing labs, released its findings about paternity testing in a landmark 1999 report. The report states that 30 percent of DNA paternity tests nationwide turn out negative, that the father tested is not the biological father.
This highlights the need for men to take steps to protect themselves against paternity fraud, and for the legal system to provide better support for men who have been the victim of this type of deception. It is also important to acknowledge the emotional impact that paternity fraud can have on all parties involved, including the child, and to approach these cases with sensitivity and compassion.
If a man has already established a relationship with a child and later suspects paternity fraud, the best course of action is to request a DNA paternity test as soon as possible. This will allow the man to make an informed decision about whether to continue his relationship with the child, and to take any legal action that may be necessary.
It is also important for men to be aware of the risks of paternity fraud, and to have open and honest conversations with their partners about paternity before establishing a relationship with a child. This can help to prevent misunderstandings and miscommunications that may lead to paternity fraud.
If you suspect paternity fraud or wish to seek further information, contact us for a free consultation by clicking the button below.
